&t skeet on mischa: Post Post Post Post Post Post Modernism

skeet on mischa

i wouldn't have given you it if i didn't agree

Nov 3, 2006

Post Post Post Post Post Post Modernism

There’s a certain point in Sofia Coppola’s Marie Antoinette where it just lost me. Up until that point, the film had been a solid double legged out into a skittish triple, but perhaps, my hunger got the best of me, but I just tuned out and kept on wondering how much longer? The film is for the most part is Barry Lyndon as if it was directed by Terrence Malick with a few wet t-shirt contest scenes (maybe NSFW) to spice things up a bit. Yet to compare Coppola’s work to Malick and Kubrick just isn’t right because Coppola really wants to be like Antonioni and Wong Kar Wai, but that’s besides the point. The film until it reaches the point where the audience just can’t stand to see another shot of Marie running around in the tall grass. Sure, the cinematography is beautiful and the production design is outstanding, but this film needed more than rich visuals to hold the audience in. When a film has no real plot or at least pretends to be a character study, then the characters and the performances need to over power the visuals.

For an hour or so, I can deal with Kirsten Dunst wandering around, feeling aloof and disconnected with the court, but there needs to be more significant development in the story than that. Lost In Translation worked for some people, myself included because of the performances by Bill Murray and Scarlett Johansson were strong and engaging. In that first hour or so, the performances in the film were funny and interesting, but as soon we see Marie dancing around in the grass for what seems like fifth or sixth time, I was ready to check out and get some dinner. It just stopped being funny and wanted to be slightly serious, even though, the film remains rather neutral about Marie Antoinette. Maybe, I just lost interest in the film because there were no more Kirsten Dunst wet t-shirt moments and Steve Coogan would appear in a scene for thirty seconds.

Marie Antoinette is an interesting mess. While Coppola is a minimalist filmmaker, she manages to fill the frame well and made a film full of rich colors and costumes, but in terms of a content, it’s just not there. If Coppola wanted to that ever elusive “If Kubrick directed a teen movie….” type of film, then she should’ve had Daniel Waters work on the script.


At 11:03 AM , Blogger Robin Brown said...

Yeah. the buzz continues to make me not care about seeing this movie at all. Oh well.

At 11:17 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nice review. The point about Coppola's aspirations is, I think, a good one.

At 1:13 PM , Anonymous Bonham Hathaway said...

I enjoyed reading your take on the film, but I really liked the movie. And I loved Dunst's performance through-out. In my opinion, if she would have tried to outshine the story, it would have been Ray or Walk The Line.

I see your side. I think it has two things going against it. One, it's the perfect type of movie for people to go in expecting a different movie, and then saying its a bad movie solely because it didn't follow what he or she expected (wanted?) the movie to be about.

It's like what George Lucas said about the new Star Wars'. It's like having a house and painting it green. And then having people tell you, "Well, you should have painted it white." Well, I didn't want to paint it white, I wanted to paint it green. It's my house. (Even though I completely disagree with this analogy for the new Star Wars'. But I think it's applicable here.)

And two, whenever you make a movie about this subject, it's going to be boring for the audience. It's just not going to be the type of movie that people are actually going to want to see. It's a good movie to make, if you have the talent to pull off the story you decided to tell, which Sofia does and did, but aesthetically, people don't really want to actually watch it, other than people interested in the craft of movie-making. (Lars Von Trier?)

At 2:29 PM , Blogger Douglas Reinhardt said...

Coppola's technique is there and all, but I just wished she'd move beyond making movies about girls starring out windows.

At 10:34 AM , Blogger Chuck Reinhardt said...

Thanks for saving Dad $8.00 on a ticket to Marie Antoinette.


Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home